Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Green Conflict Industry in High Gear


The “Green Conflict Industry” may be a new term to recent followers of The General’s blog. GCI has been around for a long time and it is no stranger to this land-use warrior.

In March, I wrote about GCI’s attack on the mountain bike community:
http://thegeneralsrecreationden.blogspot.com/2009/03/peer-sends-love-letter-to-imba.html



Later in March, I wrote a longer blog on other examples of how GCI attacks even responsible OHV use of public and private lands:
http://thegeneralsrecreationden.blogspot.com/2009/03/rta-trojan-horse-or-skunk-at-party.html



Recently, GCI has reared its ugly head in two places:

STOCKTON RECORD ARTICLE (Sept. 29) A lawsuit filed again Carnegie State Vehicular Recreation Area (with a quote from Don Amador/BRC)
http://www.recordnet.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20090929/A_NEWS/909290323/-1/A_NEWS14#STS=g06pr6xj.19tz



CBD Lawsuit Filed (Sept 9) to Close Eldorado NF OHV Routes
http://biologicaldiversity.org/news/press_releases/2009/eldorado-09-09-2009.html



OHV/BRC has fought back and won on a number of previous cases including the original Clear Creek ESA-based lawsuit and Eldorado National Forest lawsuit. More battles are assured as GCI challenges to OHV recreation continue to mount.

Our task is to never give up and let GCI get us down. Gear-up is what we need to do.





Thursday, September 24, 2009

The General is in the Field - Sept. 24-27

The General is in the field. Will return to HQ on Mon.

Wednesday, September 23, 2009

"Blessed" Routes Closed in Current MVUM


In a recent blog, The General advised his followers to “hold the Forest Service accountable” particularly when it comes to travel management planning. A good
case study of a unit being unaccountable is the Smith River National Recreation Area.
*Photo: Trail that is open and blessed on the 1994 Forest Visitor Map, yet it is closed on the current MVUM

In 1990, President George Bush signed the Smith River National Recreation Area Act.
http://www.smithriveralliance.org/resources/library/SmithRiverNRAAct.pdf



As you know, the NRA just published a MVUM that was apparently based on a pre-Act
(circa 1990 Forest Visitor Map - with many OHV routes not being shown) rather than basing the MVUM on the post-Act 1994 Forest Visitor Map (that showed NRA/Act “blessed” OHV routes) as was promised to the Del Norte County Board of Supervisors.

The Forest’s current and past rationale for making such ad hoc decisions (i.e. to arbitrarily close roads and trails without project level NEPA) is based on their false belief that the 1990 Act gave the NRA “special authority” to bypass the NEPA process and just close routes as they see fit.

The crazy thing is that in the 1995 Forest Plan it references that OHV projects should be “scheduled” to implement OHV use on trails and roads. See excerpt from 1995 Forest Plan:

******************************************************************




Page 13
Off-Highway Vehicle
(OHV) Management
Strategies
Assess areas for OHV use. Schedule projects to implement
vehicle use in some areas and restrict use in other areas.
As needed Recreation
Transportation Management
Strategy
.
Assess transportation system and use. Schedule projects to
construct, reconstruct, or decommission roads based on
anticipated needs.
1998 Engineering
****************************************************************************


Yet over the years and until BRC and local stakeholders started to complain about ad hoc closures, the NRA had been doing aggressive road decommissioning/obliteration without any (in most cases) project level NEPA to back up the work. It appears the NRA continues to use this invalid rationale to deny public access to “blessed” routes via its current MVUM.

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

OHV Commission Meeting in Lake Arrowhead - Sept 24/25

FYI for any riders who can make some or all of the OHV commission meeting in Lake Arrowhead. It's a good chance to make your views known on access issues and to give feedback to the commission and department.

See News Release for Commission Meeting Sept 24-25, 2009
http://ohv.parks.ca.gov/pages/1140/files/Press%20Release_Commission%20mtg%20September%2009.pdf

Thanks for your service!

Monday, September 21, 2009

GOOD NEWS - Fed Judge Blocks Green Prelim Injunction


The General does his best to share good news on the rare occasion that it happens with his followers. Just recently, Judge Donald W. Molloy, a federal district court judge in Montana, denied a request by environmental groups to stop -via a motion for preliminary injunction - wolf hunts in Montana and Idaho.

News stories on Decision:
http://www.idahostatesman.com/localnews/story/894431.html

(includes quote from Paul Turcke) AND

http://www.ktvq.com/Global/story.asp?S=10982463




Paul Turcke’s (BRC’s legal counsel as well) Filing on the Wolf Case
http://www.sharetrails.org/uploads/Wolf-ESA_Case/Wolf_Turcke_PI_memo_FINAL_8-27-09.pdf




We all know of or have been victims of lawsuits filed by extreme anti-OHV groups where they petitioned a court at the eleventh hour to stop a permitted OHV event(s) or activities.

This decision, correctly in The General’s view, acknowledges important U.S. Supreme Court precedent from last summer that rejects a 9th Circuit formula regularly used to justify injunctions in Endangered Species Act and other “environmental” cases. In case you’re wondering, against the anti’s cries of impending doom, as of today there have been a total of four (4) wolves taken in the Idaho season, against more than a hundred “control” actions in which wolves were killed in 2008.

The General believes that the correct interpretation of “new law” reflected by this decision should make it harder for anti-OHV groups to stop permitted OHV events or activities under the threat, or even filing, of a lawsuit. This is a very important development in the OHV legal arena.

NV OHV Program - A Blessing or a Curse?


Recounting the pros and cons of your marriage is how some riders view state OHV programs. On the good side, some off-roaders believe their state OHV program is the greatest thing since sliced bread since those efforts help support riding areas with monies for trail maintenance and construction. Sometimes OHV-related education, safety, and law enforcement are funded as well.
*
Photo: The General on FS Lands Near Reno, NV
*
On the bad side, some state OHV programs appear to be nothing more than a not so complex scheme devised by anti-OHV groups or other interests (and sometimes supported by well-meaning OHV groups) to control and subsequently reduce OHV recreation in that state.

After talking with a number of riders from Nevada, I think the jury is still out on the new Nevada OHV/DMV Registration Program.
*
NV Registration Program
http://www.dmvnv.com/motorcycle.htm#ATVs

*
New NV FS/BLM Trail Ethic Website
http://www.nevada-ohv.org/index.html

*
Will the NV OHV Program be a blessing or a curse? That question will have to be answered by the off-roaders who live in Nevada.

Friday, September 18, 2009

Comment Enabled for Followers

The General fixed a glitch so that Followers can now post comments. Please
feel free to take the time to comment on my recent post on creation of
new Widerness areas or any other of my recent blogs.

Thanks for your service!!! (and comments)