Thursday, September 17, 2009

TMR Now Used to "Create" new Wilderness Areas


The General believes that on a growing number of National Forests - TMR has actually very little to do with addressing “repeated cross-country travel.” Rather, it appears to be laying the groundwork for future Wilderness designations by green groups and Congress.
*
Photo: Note mapped OHV routes - arrows point to OHV routes - that were on the 1994 Forest Map that have either been closed by the new MVUM or other decision (click on map for large format)
*

Nowhere is this “Wilderness creation” concept more evident than on the Smith River National Recreation Area in Northern California where a series of agency management decisions over the last decade have successfully to date banned motorized use on once legal OHV trails that were on official Forest Maps.

See Decision on 2000/2001 BRC Appeal where we offered a managed recreation alternative and it was rejected by the FS:
http://www.fs.fed.us/r5/ecoplan/appeals/2001/fy01_0079.htm


Just recently, the NRA published its new MVUM. As you may know, The General (on behalf of the BRC) and Del Norte County appealed and won regarding the unit’s attempt to misuse the Roadless Rule as an excuse to close mapped OHV routes in a previous TMR EA. Now the agency has used a provision in TMR whereby they simply identify “system routes” that are available for wheeled vehicle use and publish the MVUM. No substantive public process is required.

If you go to the NRA’s North Dist. Map, you will see a large block of land where use of mapped OHV routes has now been banned or was banned in a previous decision. It is a strange coincidence that public use has been banned of all mapped OHV routes in the High Plateau Mountain/Diamond Creek area and that this area mirrors the exact outline of a Proposed Wilderness Area.

N. Dist. MVUM (note large blank area in center of map)
http://fs.usda.gov/Internet/FSE_DOCUMENTS/stelprdb5084307.pdf


Some of you may remember that in the North Coast Wild Heritage Wilderness Bill (HR233) that enviros used the rationale for new Wilderness Areas in areas that had historic and legal OHV use as follows: “…our Wilderness proposal will not close any currently legal OHV riding.” How convenient?

While protecting landscapes that meet true 1964 Wilderness Act characteristics may have value on a case-by-case basis, the OHV community should be alerted to the potential that current and future Forest planning efforts (including TMR) can and will be used to “create” new Wilderness areas out of lands once used by the public on OHVs.
*
# # #

Tuesday, September 15, 2009

TMR Bermuda Triangle Found Near Reno


A very troubling trend is emerging nationwide in the ongoing saga of the Forest Service’s Travel Management planning effort. On a growing number of Forests, the current stage of TMR has very little to do with addressing repeated cross-country travel by OHVs as outlined in The Chief’s now infamous 2004 “4 Threats Speech.”
*
*
*
*
*
*

*

*
Rather, it appears that Forests such as the Shasta-Trinity, Mount Hood, and Humboldt-Toiyabe (and many others) are using TMR as a closure tool to make motorized public access and recreation to public lands an endangered species.


*

*
Yesterday on behalf of BRC, I submitted comments on the Bridgeport Ranger District’s DEIS.


*
*
The letter points out that the DEIS is in effect a blanket closure. One concept that is described in the letter is where the agency has created a TMR-related “Bermuda Triangle.” That is where route information submitted by groups and riders from Friends of Wilson Canyon, Dirt Tricks.com, and other interests mysteriously disappeared into a bureaucratic black hole never to be seen or heard of again.

Where TMR goes from here is up to the agency. It appears they are at a cross-road where they can make the choice to get TMR back on the right trail or head off the path and into a steep ravine.

# # #





Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Howling at the Moon in OR to Stop OHV Use


As many of my readers know, TMR is a national blessing or curse depending on what your own local Forest is proposing to close or keep open for OHV use.
*
*Photo at right taken by The General while on a 2004 dual sport ride on the Mt. Hood NF
*

Just last week, The General received in his mail a copy of the CD version of the Mount Hood National Forest Travel DEIS. Several years ago on behalf of BRC, I submitted public comments on the Hood’s TMR NOI. My initial review of the DEIS shows the Forest actually incorporated a number of our suggestions by converting some roads to trails, designating some areas, and proposing some new trails.

However, the scale of those good ideas is so small as to be almost irrelevant when compared with the fact that over 90 percent of the logging roads (over 2100 miles) will be closed to non-street legal OHVs (ATVs, dirt-bikes, and side-by-sides)

See Sandy Post Article (with quotes from BRC and BARK)
http://www.sandypost.com/news/story.php?story_id=125245623636788600


It looks like the local anti-OHV group in the area (BARK) has been very effective by going to public meetings and howling or barking at public officials in order to get the Forest Service to adopt much if not most of their anti-OHV proposals.

BARK
http://bark-out.org/topic.php?id=mthoodohv


I have already been in touch with representatives from the
OR Motorcycle Riders Assn (see this thread for meeting times)
http://www.omraoffroad.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7003


and Columbia Gorge Off Road Assn
http://cgora.com/


BRC will be working with these and other groups during the DEIS public comment period.

Being a native of Humboldt County in Northern California (don’t hold that against me!) I am used to seeing bizarre eco-groups. However, BARK appears to have developed an effective strategy in the Mount Hood Area by howling at the moon (and at public officials) to get their way.

I wonder how that technique would work for off-roaders if they tried it at the next OHV meeting or included photo shopped pictures of wolves riding ATVs in their comment letters?

TMR is not just a CA thing.

Monday, August 31, 2009

HOLDING THE FOREST SERVICE ACCOUNTABLE


My Dad gave me his 3 timeless axioms for a successful and happy life when I was but a youngster and those are:
*
1- Be a man of your word
*
2- Be to work on time
*
3- Don’t let people pour water down your neck and tell you it is raining (his original version was more graphic)
*
PHOTO - Don Amador on tour of proposed trail closures on the Shasta Trinity NF
*
Back in 2001/2002, Forest Service officials looked me square in the eye and promised that the California Route Inventory and Designation Process (RID) - now known as the Travel Management Rule - would not be used as a closure tool to get RID of trails.

Turn the clock forward to today where the Shasta Trinity National Forest is proposing to close basically all of their 800 miles of single-track motorcycle trails and ATV trails less than 50 inches in width. Be assured, I am and will be asking the Forest Service to keep their word. You should do the same.
*
BRC and Shasta County Comment Letters on the Shasta Trinity DEIS
http://www.sharetrails.org/uploads/Shasta-Trinity_NF/
*
VIDEO – Don Amador Talks About Holding The Forest Service Accountable
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y0xm7OQsfTI
*
Thanks for your service!

Thursday, August 27, 2009

Shasta County Supervisors Weigh In on Shasta NF DEIS


So far in the travel management saga, I have received the most email and responses on this issue from users, retired FS employees (including recreation officers and regional foresters), and others who are extremely disappointed in the Shasta Trinity National Forest’s DEIS and its proposal to close virtually ALL (over 800 miles) of the Forest’s single track motorcycle trails and ATV trails (see letter from Shasta County Board of Supervisors below). County officials have a key role in standing up for the public’s access rights.
*
Photo is of a volunteer with the Redding Dirt Riders enjoying an ATV trail that would be closed in the DEIS
*
* Aug 25, 2009 Shasta County BOS Letter to Shasta Trinity National Forest on TMR DEIS http://www.sharetrails.org/uploads/Shasta-Trinity_NF/Shasty%20County%20Comments%20on%20STNF%20DEIS-08.25.09.pdf

*


Again, I believe that the Forest should withdraw the current DEIS and issue a supplemental DEIS that includes a “citizen’s recreation alternative.” That alternative could be the product of collaboration between users, local government, and the agency.
# # #

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Shasta Trinity NF DEIS - Closed Trails and Broken Promises


On August 25, 2009 - The General (on behalf of the BlueRibbon Coalition) sent in formal comments on the Shasta Trinity National Forest’s DEIS for Travel Management.
*
Photo: This is the Idaho-style single track trail called - The Dubakellas Trail. It is proposed to be closed to OHV use in the DEIS.

*
BRC Aug. 25, 2009 Comments on Shasta Trinity NF including exhibits
http://www.sharetrails.org/uploads/Shasta-Trinity_NF/

*

*


Regrettably for both users and the agency, this is the best (or worst) example of TMR “gone wrong” in California so far. Basically all of the action alternatives close almost 100% of the existing motorcycle only trails and ATV trails <>
*
See my May blog on the origins of the CA RID process for some perspective
http://thegeneralsrecreationden.blogspot.com/2009/05/travel-management-good-idea-or-big.html

*

*

The General hopes that Forest leadership will review public comments (users, local governments, and other stakeholders) and push the “reset button” on TMR. I believe the Forest should withdraw the DEIS and issue a supplemental DEIS that includes a viable recreation alternative that designates a significant number of historic OHV routes. A blanket closure of almost 100% of their motorcycle only and ATV trails is unrealistic, unfair, a violation of public trust, and runs counter to promises made by Region 5 staff to BRC that TMR would not be used as a closure tool.

# # #




Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Rock The Trail 2009 Update


Back in June, The General wrote about getting celebrities, artists, musicians, and actors more involved in helping support (and join) our efforts to keep trails open for responsible OHV recreation.
*


*

*
Well, it appears that some stars may be up to that challenge based on a lunch meeting I had yesterday with a retired NFL player with two Super Bowl rings.

2009 may just be the year that OHV access groups “Rock the Trail” with new support from various celebrities who want to help us preserve and protect our right to access recreational opportunities on public lands.


# # #