Showing posts with label OHV cost recovery. Show all posts
Showing posts with label OHV cost recovery. Show all posts
Tuesday, May 3, 2011
Congressional Fix Needed to Address OHV Permitted Event Boondoggle
The ongoing assault on permitted OHV events is a complex issue. First, you have “cost recovery” which has its genesis in the 1952 Independent Offices Appropriations Act. Second, categorical exclusions (CEs) for OHV permitted events (and some other project level activities such as prescribed burns) are now required to have a public notice, a comment period, and a formal appeals process thanks to a 2005 court ruling.
According to BRC "... on July 2, 2005 the United States District Court for the Eastern District of California issued an Order banning the use of CEs. The ruling requires any forest project using a CE to include a formal public notice, be available for public comment and give the public the option of appealing the decision. The order applies to all decisions made with a CE after July 7, 2005. It also applies nationwide."
Linked below is congressional testimony from Mark Rey on the CE court ruling (a good overview)
http://www.fs.fed.us/congress/109/house/oversight/rey/111505.html
HQ believes tackling the many bureaucratic hurdles that face permitted OHV and other recreational events is an important task. Over recent years, we have seen many OHV events cancelled and/or postponed because of onerous regulations and red tape.
HQ believes that a congressional fix to this issue is the proper long-term solution. Several key tenets for legislative solutions could include the following:
COST RECOVERY/IOAA
“Exempt OHV permitted events from cost recovery on units that receive supplemental funding (e.g. state OHV grants, etc.)”
CEs
“Exempt CEs for OHV permitted events from public notice, public review, and a formal appeals process where said event uses designated roads, trails, and areas.”
With a new round of DEM and GOP Wilderness bills lurking in the background, this might be the perfect time to propose a fix for the recreation permit issue if there are to be any pro-access compromises offered in these bills as a way to move them forward. Also, we should do outreach to other user groups since they are being impacted too. I envision a bill with a lot of support from diverse recreational interests.
New Round of Wilderness Bills in 2011
http://www.nytimes.com/gwire/2011/05/03/03greenwire-wilderness-bills-proliferate-as-promoters-hope-16290.html
Be assured The Quiet Warrior has placed this topic high on his “stack of stuff” to address in 2011 and will continue to develop ideas for proposed legislation.
Wednesday, July 21, 2010
OHV Cost Recovery Fight on Eldorado NF

The Recreation HQ has been working with AMA D36 and others to address the issue of exorbitant fees being charged to clubs for permitted events by some FS units under the guise of “cost recovery.”
*
PHOTO: The General riding one of the event trails for the 2006 Fools Gold Enduro
*
Overview of 2006 FS Cost Recovery Program
http://www.fs.fed.us/r8/caribbean/passes/cr-communication-plan_feb06.doc
Overview of 2006 FS Cost Recovery Program
http://www.fs.fed.us/r8/caribbean/passes/cr-communication-plan_feb06.doc
The Eldorado Fight was recently highlighted in this Sac Bee article
http://www.sacbee.com/2010/07/18/2897662/canceled-forest-recreation-events.html
http://www.sacbee.com/2010/07/18/2897662/canceled-forest-recreation-events.html
Also, HQ’s friend Jon Crowley wrote an opinion piece
http://sxsnews.com/index.php/2010/07/the-public-pays-extortionary-fees-to-use-public-land/
The public process for the 2006 Cost Recovery Rule actually started back in 1999. BRC urged its members to comment as well as submitting its own formal comments.
2000 BRC Cost Recovery Article and Concerns
http://www.sharetrails.org/magazine/article/?id=1222
As some of you know, the focus of the aforementioned cancelled permitted OHV events is on the Eldorado National Forest. The General along with leaders of CERA and AMA D36 met with the Forest Supervisor to express our strong concerns and objections to the unit’s misuse of cost recovery to essentially bankrupt several OHV clubs.
The Forest did not really have an answer to our questions about why their cost recovery charges are so extreme when other federal units (Mendocino NF, Cow Mountain, Chappie-Shasta, and CCMA when it was open, etc.) with AMA-sanctioned permitted events have more reasonable charges.
The General will say what the Forest was afraid to state. HQ believes the high cost being charged to clubs is because there is a nationally-recognized anti-OHV leader who is a vexatious litigant. She lives on the Forest and uses her green legal clout as a club to beat the Forest Service into submission with legal action or threats of legal action unless the agency uses cost recovery to put the clubs out-of-business.
Description of Vexatious Litigant
http://www.gillhams.com/dictionary/145.cfm
The issue of cost recovery is complex. Riders must understand that the issuance of permits for most recreational events is totally discretionary. At the end of the day, the FS does not have to issue a permit if it does not want to. HQ does not believe that litigation regarding the Eldorado issue has judicial merit at this time. Rather, OHVers should look to resolve this issue via regulatory reform or political pressure.
Here are several suggestions.
1 – AMA, BRC, and other national groups should seek amendments or revisions to the cost recovery rule that might allow the agency more flexibility when faced with a vexatious litigant or other adverse circumstance.
2 – Congress might have a role in passing legislation to address exorbitant fees
3 – Congress should pass EAJA reform to discourage and not reward vexatious litigants
with taxpayer funded awards.
HQ is certain there are answers - albeit not easy ones - to this issue. OHV clubs that use the Eldorado NF are seeing the ugly side of OHV Wars. Enviros have perfected the fine art of green litigation to stop OHV recreation (and other uses such as farming in the Central Valley, logging on federal lands, etc.).
BRC working with other OHV partners have been and will continue to fight back. One recent victory regarding TMR is noted in the MIC press release below:
MIC News Release on recent TMR victory where trails and campgrounds were reopened
http://www.mic.org/news070210.cfm
Just how the Eldorado NF cost recovery issue is resolved is yet to be determined. One thing for sure is that the OHV community cannot give up and let the extreme enviros succeed in kicking us out of the Forest.
Thanks for your commitment and service!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
