Friday, August 14, 2009

Friday Update on Roadless Issue and OHV Access


The General has received a number of PMs from riders who want to know a little bit more about the roadless battle and how BRC’s legal effort got started and why we were concerned about access to trails and jeep roads in “roadless areas.”
********************************************
Photo at right is of designated OHV trail in an Eldorado NF "Roadless" Area.
*********************************************

The onus for our effort was based on the fact the Shasta-Trinity NF (circa 2000-2001) had actually decided not to reconstruct jeep trails in their roadless areas near McCloud.
*


*

*

Again, riders and access interests should continue to monitor the roadless issue and advise BRC if trails or jeep roads are being excluded from designation based on a false interpretation of the Clinton Roadless Rule.
*

Green Groups Defend OHV Trails in Roadless Areas


With the “roadless” issue in the news today, The General wants to remind riders to be ever vigilant on your watch regarding the designation (or lack thereof) of OHV trails in roadless areas.

See LA Times Article with quote from BRC’s Attorney – Paul Turcke
http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-court-roads6-2009aug06,0,1222397.story


BRC has long held and argued that the Clinton Roadless Rule was illegal. Those of us involved in the issue (myself since 1998) knew that no plan crafted in a DC smoke-filled room would past muster.

On behalf of the BRC, I had reminded many Forests (including our successful appeal on the Six Rivers NF) in the TMR process of the following facts:

The BlueRibbon Coalition believes that Region 5 and the Smith River NRA have improperly concluded that existing routes within “roadless areas” must be closed and/or not designated as a result of the 2001 Roadless Rule. This interpretation is contrary to the plain language of that Rule. In fact, the strongest proponents of the Roadless Rule have consistently pointed to the fact that the Rule preserves existing motorized access in defending the Rule as a necessary and balanced management tool.

Preservationist interests “defended” motorized access to roadless areas in their strong opposition to the intervention of access-advocacy interests in California ex rel Lockyer et al. v. U.S.D.A., Case No. 05-3508 (N.D.Cal.). That case, consolidated with a similar action brought by private groups led by The Wilderness Society (“TWS”) sought to challenge the 2005 State Petitions Rule. The California Association of 4 Wheel Drive Clubs, United Four Wheel Drive Associations, American Council of Snowmobile Associations and BlueRibbon Coalition moved to intervene. The preservationist plaintiffs opposed, arguing “the interests that the Off-Road Vehicle Groups assert in motorized recreation in roadless areas are not at stake in this action.” Plaintiffs’ Opposition to Motion to Intervene (Doc. No. 79) at 7 Case Nos. 05-3508 and 05-4038 (N.D.Cal.)(March 7, 2006) In reaching this conclusion, the TWS plaintiffs summarized language from the Rule and its associated planning documents, stating “[i]n sum, even if the Roadless Rule is reinstated by this Court as plaintiffs request, it will not prohibit a single person’s off-road vehicle use or close a single off-road vehicle trail as alleged by the Off-Road Vehicle Groups’ declarants.” Id. at 5. The TWS surreply clarifies and extends on these conclusions, again saying the “Roadless Rule does not close any existing vehicular routes (ORV or otherwise) in any National Forest roadless areas.” Plaintiffs’ Surreply in Opposition to Intervention (Doc. No. 100) at 1, Case Nos. 05-3508 and 05-4038 (N.D.Cal.)(March 24, 2006) . That document goes on to address specific routes of concern identified by BlueRibbon declarant Don Amador and says “[a]s to the two routes Mr. Amador might hypothetically use for ORV recreation … neither route is more than 50 inches wide, and therefore the Roadless Rule would not even apply to them.” Id. at 2.

Riders should support those Forests who have correctly interpreted the Clinton Roadless Rule as allowing for designated OHV trails in inventoried roadless areas. If local users spot a trail that has been excluded from designation based on the “roadless” issue, they should cite the above information and remind the Forest that green groups support OHV trails in roadless areas.

As Turcke stated in the LA article…The Roadless Saga Continues.


*

Monday, August 10, 2009

Statesmanship and OHV Advocacy


The General believes it is helpful to occasionally go back in time and review a specific land-use event that may give riders insight into an agency action and what the OHV community’s response was or should have been and if that response was effective.

The case-study for today is the post-Angora-fire decision by the Tahoe National Forest to ban OHV use on their trail network during the summer of 2007 because of critical fire danger.

FS 2007 News Release with OHV Restrictions
http://www.fs.fed.us/r5/tahoe/news/07_news_releases/07_jun_29_addl_fire_rest.shtml
*
*
*
*
*

As the western representative for the BlueRibbon Coalition, I was shocked by the Forest’s rather unprecedented action to ban OHV use even on designated trails. Historically, most Forests allow OHV use on their trail and road networks – even through times of critical fire danger – since OHVs operating with legal spark arresters on trails are not considered a fire danger.

The closure was met with fierce opposition by many riders who wanted OHV groups to file a lawsuit or raise hell in some form or fashion. However, another tactic was employed by The General and several other organizational leaders and that effort included us voicing our strong objection to the unwarranted closure while also stating our equally strong feelings and understanding about the devastating impacts of the recent Angora Fire on the local community and Forest Service staff.

I believe our message of objection and concern about the unprecedented temporary trail closure combined with a thread of understanding and support including our request that the agency keep OHV trails open in future orders related to critical fire conditions resulted in OHV trails remaining open in this year’s Fire Closure Order
*
*
*

Many times in land-use advocacy the easy way would be to throw red meat to the masses by making undeliverable promises of revenge, litigation, and retribution on agency staff that do not do our bidding. While taking the agency to task on policy issues is legitimate and sometimes necessary, there will come an occasion where you have to blend advocacy, policy, access, effectiveness, and statesmanship into a position that looks at the big picture and considers the human element. Is making the right call easy? Not always, but it should be.

# # #

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

New GAO OHV Report - Biased and Flawed


Some of you may be aware of a newly released “OHV Study” by the Government Accountability Office. When the GAO first came up with the initial concept of this survey, the BRC and several other OHV groups were asked to review the survey questions and give input. On behalf of the BRC, The General had given his input to BRC leadership regarding the proposed questions/survey.

****************************************************************
BRC News Release on GAO Report – (GAO report is linked in the news release)
http://www.sharetrails.org/releases/media/?print=1&story=654

***************************************************************

*

*

*******************************************************************

Feb 2009 OHV Group Letter to GAO About Design Flaws
http://www.sharetrails.org/uploads/Letter_To_GAO.pdf


*******************************************************************


It was his impression that the new survey was filled with double-negative (i.e. have you stopped beating your wife type questions?) questions. This design flaw was pointed out to the GAO, but they refused to change the survey design.

Hence, we end up with yet another “OHV Report/Survey” that is strangely similar to previous Forest Service reports issues in 1985 and 1996. Rather then focus on the need for positive and pro-active management prescriptions or philosophies and cite those units with said tenets, the survey casts a wide net of double-negatives that ultimately results in the GAO making the same tired observations that land management agencies often have no time, no money, and no staff (and no desire in many cases) to manage OHV recreation.

The GAO report is government at its worse. The report is uninspiring and appears to leave the reader with the impression that if OHV recreation is to be sustainable and successful that programs must have good planning, deal with conflict resolution, and have adequate law enforcement. Sure those are key tenets to a successful program, but the report fails to capture the main ingredient to a quality OHV program – people that care.

It has been my observation over the last 20 years of recreation advocacy that if a unit has an agency OHV champion such as a recreation officer, district ranger, forest supervisor, OHV program manager, or area manager… that unit will have a good OHV program.

However, if the unit does not have an agency OHV champion… no amount of law enforcement, public meetings, or planning will substitute for that person’s commitment to have a good OHV program that both protects resources and provides a quality recreation experience.

Thanks to the managers who care. I salute you!

Thursday, July 30, 2009

The General is on R & R

The General will be on R & R for the next few days. Will be back at HQ on Aug 4 - 0800 hours.

Wednesday, July 29, 2009

July 29 Update on Parks/OHV - Video Included


Based on feedback from a number of riders wanting to know the bottom line on the OHV Program and the State Park System, I wanted to give you my “quick and dirty” overview of the status as it stands today from my perspective.
**************************************
Photo at right is BRC's Don Amador on Tolowa
State Park near the OR Border - a park
that could be on the chopping block
**************************************

OHMVR – The Good – The core OHV program (SVRAs and grants – approx. 60 million dollars) stays intact.


OHMVR - The Bad - $112 million dollars “borrowed” from several special accounts. Who knows when it will be repaid? The prospect of purchasing new lands for OHV at anytime in the near future looks grim.

STATE PARKS - More Bad - They take a $52 million dollar hit (or 21% reduction) for this year and next. Park administration will wait until after Labor Day to close up to 100 or more non-SVRA units.

5 MONTH BUDGET CYCLE – Even Worse - Sacramento will have to do this all over again (another round of budget cuts at best guess) in a few months.

*******************************************************************
Don Amador’s Video Message to Users – Stay Engaged and Involved – Also take advantage of new Rocky Mtn. ATV/BRC Membership Program
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NHpxsczkSp8


*******************************************************************
*
*
*********************************************************************

Rocky Mtn. ATV/BRC Membership Drive
https://www.sharetrails.org/secure/rmatvmc/


*******************************************************************


Thanks for your interest and support on land use issues.

Tuesday, July 28, 2009

State Park/OHMVR Update - Parks Takes a Hit


While many folks are cheering the Governor as he signed the budget today, the General is left with the impression that he witnessed a very dark and ugly day in California’s history.

*************************************
Photo at right is from my recent trip to
Rockefeller Forest at Redwood State
Park near Fortuna
*************************************
When the Assembly did not approve the budget enhancements (off-shore drilling and taking gas taxes from local governments) the $1 billion dollar hole had to be filled with additional cuts.

The California State Park budget appears to have been one of those targets as well as the OHMVR Program. Although it appears the OHMVR operations (SVRAs and day-to-day administrative duties) and grants program stays intact, the fact remains that over $110 million dollars was “borrowed” from special OHV accounts. That means there will be basically no capital outlay projects or acquisitions for the foreseeable future.

The landscape that used to be the Golden State is now faced with a state park system that may close 100 or more non-SVRA units. State Parks is tasked with a very difficult issue. Also, OHMVR will have to put on hold any plans for new areas.

Certainly the long-term sustainability of State Parks will be based on their ability to find partners, sponsors, and creative methods (we should support those efforts) to become self-supported and more of a user-pay/user benefit program such as the OHV or Boating and Waterways programs.

Also, we are on a 5 month budget cycle so that means we may be doing this all over again in a few months.

If there is a silver lining in the clouds… it is a fact that because of a lot of hard work by unsung heroes (I know who you are and I SALUTE YOU!)… our OHV Program remains. It reminds me of the famous image of the metal structure at the Twin Towers – a Phoenix rising out of the ashes.

Sure things look dark now, but it is during hard times that Californians buck it up and get’er done. Let’s just hope that our leaders in Sacramento have that same metal.

# # #